Who I introduce through my “Religion in Global Context” class

In my last post, I listed philosophers, intellectuals, and even a poet that feature into my “Philosophy for Human Flourishing” class, whether it be for a line, a paragraph, a video, a whole reading, or even a whole lesson built around their ideas. Now, let me share who my comparative religion/theory of religion course introduces (again, in order of appearance):

  • Christian Smith
  • Jonathan Z. Smith
  • Andrew Mark Henry
  • Simran Jeet Singh
  • Daniel Dennett
  • Ludwig Wittgenstein
  • Jason Anada Josephson Storm
  • Hussein Rashid
  • Maimonides
  • Alan Verskin
  • Laura Carlson Hasler
  • Max Daniel
  • Joshua Shanes
  • Siddhartha Gautama
  • Arjuna C.B. Ranatunga
  • Nick Swan
  • Sarah Shaw
  • Dhivan Thomas Jones
  • Christopher V. Jones
  • the 14th Dalai Lama
  • Cathy Cantrell

Not quite as many new names and faces as my philosophy class, but still a lot!

Who I introduce through my “Philosophy for Human Flourishing” class

The curriculum for “Philosophy for Human Flourishing” looks stable after four semesters of teaching it. It will stay the same going into spring and summer versions, and likely next fall and spring as well. So, who does this class introduce students to in its present form? Here’s a list by order of appearance (some being the center of whole lessons; some being quoted just a line or a paragraph):

  • Socrates/Plato
  • Rainer Maria Rilkke
  • Peter Singer
  • Ludwig Wittgenstein
  • Raymond Geuss
  • Clare Carlisle
  • Wilfred Sellars
  • Pierre Hadot
  • Hannan Arendt
  • Frederick Douglass
  • Agnes Callard
  • Robert Nozick
  • John Rawls
  • Cornell West
  • Simon Critchley
  • Aristotle
  • Immanuel Kant
  • Jeremy Bentham/John Stuart Mill
  • Valerie Tiberius
  • Shel Silverstein
  • Epicurus
  • Epictetus
  • Rebecca Newberger Goldstein
  • Frederich Nietzsche

Next year, a new spring class looks likely and it’ll be titled “Faith Seeking Understanding: Reason, God, and the Problem of Evil” and it’ll introduce a lot more philosophical theologians and theological philosophers.

Talarico’s sermon

I want to mark this date and share these excerpts from a great sermon…eh, victory speech, by the soon-to-be Senator from Texas, James Talarico:

This win is not about the Democratic Party or the Republican Party. It’s much bigger than that. There is something broken in America. Our economic system is broken. Our political system is broken. Even our relationships with each other feel broken. That’s because the most powerful people in the world want it that way.

My granddad was a Baptist preacher in South Texas and when I was little, he told me that we follow a barefoot rabbi who gave us two commandments, “love God and love neighbor.” Because there is no love of God without love of neighbor. Every single person bears the image of the sacred. Every single person is holy.

Not just my neighbor who looks like me. Not just my neighbor who prays like me. Not just my neighbor who votes like me. I am called to love all of my neighbors the way I love myself.

My faith teaches me that love is the strongest force in the universe. Love is not passive. Love is not neutral. Love is not weak. Love requires that we stand between the bullies and the bullied. Love requires that we look evil in the eye and not blink. That kind of love has always been a threat to the powers that be. That kind of love is revolutionary.

That kind of love is creative. Hate is predictable. Hate is boring. Hate can’t lower our energy bills. Hate can’t teach a child to read. Hate can’t build a future. But what hate can’t do, love can.

Love can turn a student into a scholar. Love can turn a closet into a nursery. Love can turn an enemy into a friend. Love can turn a campaign into a movement. Love can heal what’s broken in America.

We can’t defeat the politics of division with more division. We can’t win that game. We have to change the game.

Do you have to have a history to appreciate history?

A few years ago, I asked my students why it is that they think we study history. The majority of them answered something like, “To learn from the mistakes of the past.” It was an almost purely negative reason. People in the past have failed to do the right thing; we can learn what to avoid. It’s like people from the past walked down a trail and some of them slipped off a cliff at a certain juncture, and the best thing their lives offer us is that now we’re aware of the pitfall.

I don’t teach history, technically. It finds its way into my classes, though. As someone who loves the study of history, I’ve struggled to relate to students who don’t get it, but I’ve also struggled with how to articulate its value to them. Is it a matter of taste with no semi-objective basis for demanding that students spend time learning it? I don’t think so, and if I’m able, maybe I’ll post a few reasons why the study of history is important, but here I’m pondering the problem.

And I think part of the problem, possibly, is that you have to have your own history to understand why HISTORY matters. If you’re 16, everything is about the future. If you’re my age, half of life is in the rearview mirror. You begin to understand that the past informs the present, and at my age, it may inform the present more than the future does. At their age, all they see is the open highway of the future, and there’s very little past to be remembered and reflected upon. This may be why younger people struggle to see the relevance of the field.

On a side note, though, things have been changing recently; I’ve often mourned the gaps in history around the San Francisco Bay Area, where I think the relatively “shorter” history of that region leads to its dismissal as an area of interest. Like an adolescent with a shorter time on earth than, say, Rome, Paris, or even New York, it’s a region that lacks a history, comparatively; therefore, especially with the influence of Silicon Valley, it spends most of its time obsessing over the future. So, maybe this isn’t just a problem for individuals, but for whole cultures. (And this isn’t to dismiss Indigenous history of that region, just that, as with much of the Indigenous past, we don’t have the written records to help us construct the stories in the way we might wish. That said, this doesn’t mean there aren’t Indigenous histories to reconstruct, because there are!)

“The Daily Scribe” v. “The Daily Stoic”

Ever since I read Yoram Hazony’s The Philosophy of Hebrew Scripture (I blogged a bit about this in 2019: “The Hebrew Prophets as Philosophers”), I’ve found myself reading the Bible like I read other ancient philosophers. For one, I admit that I don’t know what to do with the category of “revelation”. But I do know that I find the Hebrew Bible and the Christian New Testament to be inspiring (positive), thought-provoking (neutral), and challenging (negative/problematic), and therefore useful to life. The one difference between how I read the Bible and how I read, say, Plato, is that the Bible is a liturgical text for me in the way Plato’s corpus isn’t. As far as their truth claims go though, I try to approach theological literature and philosophical literature with a similar mixture of a hermeneutic of suspicion and a hermeneutic of trust.

With this in mind, I want to share a new project from Jacob Wright of Emory University’s Chandler School of Theology. It’s called “The Daily Scribe”. If you know about “The Daily Stoic,” started by Ryan Holiday, you’ll have a sense of what Wright is trying to do. Except that Wright thinks that daily insights from the scribes who wrote the Bible are better for you because, as he says, “The Stoics taught you to stand alone. The Scribes knew better.” “If the Roman Stoics represent imperial power, the Biblical Scribes represent defeat and loss. They were writing in the darkest of days. Yet they found a way to invent hope. Understanding how they did is what The Daily Scribe is all about.” The authors of the Bible taught the importance of interdependence in a way that Stoicism doesn’t. I’m intrigued by this, and I’ve signed up for the daily email. If you’re interested, avoid googling it, because “The Daily Scribe” leads to a lot of places. The website URL is the-daily-scribe.com.

Related, Wright has launched doomscrollingthebible.com. This website is based on his book Why the Bible Began: An Alternative History of Scripture and Its Origins. The idea is similar: to focus on the Bible as a book “born from defeat as ‘literature for losers’ (i.e., for most of us on most days)”.

“Sentient” and “Sensory” routes to nostalgia

The other day, I posted about “random picturesque memories” that pop into my mind and leave me wanting to experience them more fully, to pause and explore why they emerged in the first place (see “Random picturesque memories”). After this, I read this week’s “Philosophy Break” from Jack Maden titled “Manufacturing Nostalgia: Paula Sweeney on Longing for How Life Once Felt,” and it drove me to read the journal article he summarizes: “Nostalgia reconsidered”. Since Maden has already summarized the article, and since it’s open access, I’ll move to why it’s relevant.

Sweeney denies that nostalgia has to be (1) “directed toward the past” or (2) “involved some salient feeling of the irretrievability of the past” (p. 187). She argues, “…that nostalgia is instead a longing for a previously experienced complex emotion that is associated with an event, or a cluster of events.” She says that “the longing is not a longing for the event of [the] past…it is a longing for the re-experiencing of the emotions that these events evoked…at the time” (p. 187). Nostalgia is present-oriented because “the power of nostalgia [is] to bring about action” (p. 187).

This leads her to clarify that there are “two apparent routes to nostalgia” (p. 188). “The first route to nostalgia we can identify through a conscious longing for a different time or place…connected to some memory or quasi memory…purposefully triggered”. “It is purposeful and considered” (p. 188). This is “the sentient route to nostalgia,” and it’s the type companies and politicians evoke to get us to buy retro products or try to move society back to “simpler times”.

On the other hand, there is “the sensory route to nostalgia” through “sensory data and it comes over you in a way that is immediate, by means of things like “smell” or a “feeling”. I think this is what I was referencing in that previous post. Sweeney says that this route is “far less predictable than the sentient route” (p. 188). I think this is basically the same sort of experience I was reflecting upon, though by a nicer, more philosophical name.

“In another life”

As I was reading this morning, I came across the phrase “In another life…” Obviously, this isn’t my first encounter with it. I’ve read it, written it, and spoken it. But this time, it stood out to me. Maybe because I’ve been thinking about the nature of soul/consciousness a bit recently (see “The Christian ‘soul,’ the Hindu ‘atman,’ and the Buddhist ‘consciousness'” and “Do human beings have souls? Does it matter?”). In most cases, this phrase isn’t being used literally, as if it is referring to a person looking back to a former form of existence. Instead, it’s used to refer back to another stage of this very life that the person is actively living. Yet I wonder if it reveals something in its use that we may not acknowledge if quizzed on our metaphysics.

I wonder if this phrase shows that we do, in a very real sense, think of ourselves as something other than what “we” were. When we say “past life” or “past self,” we acknowledge both continuation and discontinuation. Is this just a feature of language, or are we revealing that we recognize that, in some way, the past version of us ceases to exist (at least, in time as we experience time), and that we are, in some way, almost completely different beings from who we were?

Now, the problem of language arises even if I say, “Yes, I think that the ‘me’ from seven years ago is a completely or almost completely different person than the ‘me’ of the present.” That problem remains that while we may speak of a former self in the third person, we also speak of them in the first person. I don’t know if this would remain true in languages other than English, but since we think through language, and our languages shape how we think, it would seem that most English-dominated thinkers would recognize this tension in the way we speak of our past and present “self”.

Random picturesque memories

There are moments when I see or hear something, and suddenly I feel like my brain provides an overlapping experience from the past. There have been times when I’ve been walking in a park in San Antonio, and suddenly a memory will flash from a walk in San Francisco, or I’m washing dishes in my home, and suddenly I’ll visualize the sink in my apartment in Portland.

I won’t claim to know a lot about human memory, but what I do know is that it’s not like replaying a video on your phone. When recalled, it’s recalled and reshaped by a present moment, and that recall forever alters the memory being brought to the surface. But there are some memories that are just random, picturesque ones. They feel like “raw” memories. They lack narrative or context, but are merely triggered. When I have them, they come and go, but I wish they would stay. I wonder to myself, “Why did I visualize that part of San Francisco or Portland just now? What is my brain trying to say about the present moment, if anything?” I wish I could pause the memory and examine it in detail, giving it some context, giving it that missing narrative meaning.

In a sense, this feeling is similar to when you wake from a dream and you have that sense of disappointment that the dream has ended, but also there’s a cloudiness as to what it was about. I have known upon waking that I wanted what I was dreaming about to be reality, or at least, I wanted to dream the dream longer. But if you were to ask me about the details of the dream, they’re fuzzy and abstract. All that remains is the feeling of the dream.

Do human beings have souls? Does it matter?

The journalist David Brooks has a new podcast with The Atlantic called The Permanent Questions. In a recent episode (“Do Human Beings Have Souls?”), he invited the Yale University philosopher Shelly Kagan to explain why he doesn’t believe humans have souls. (Kagan may be best known for his YouTube lecture series from his course “Death”.) Overall, while Brooks was a gracious host, he was out of his league with Kagan. Brooks arguments for the existence of a soul came down to what felt like vibes; Kagan kept acknowledging the value of soul-language to explain certain elements of the human experience, but then would show that this doesn’t necessitate a non-material thing.

Personally, I think what people have called “Atman” or “Psyche” or “Soul” or whatever is best understood as what we tend to call “consciousness” now. To be fair, I don’t think we understand consciousness like we’d like to, so that leaves it with a mysterious aura akin to what “soul” means for many people. I have written a bit about this already (see “The Christian ‘soul,’ the Hindu ‘atman,’ and the Buddhist ‘consciousness'”). And I don’t think this is incompatible with Christian teaching, since, as Kagan himself notes, early Christians affirmed the resurrection of the body because they thought that we are bodied beings, not (merely?) embodied souls. I imagine that we’re something like code. The code I am now gives way to the coding that will create and sustain me in seven minutes, seven days, seven months, and seven years, respectively. The coding that I am now is based on the coding that I was seven minutes, seven days, seven months, and seven years ago, respectively. If resurrection is an event, I would concede that the resurrected “me” of the future is different from the me of the present, but also a continuation because of a “sense” of identity, memories, network of relations, sense of body in space and time, etc. This is not a problem because I think this is the same basic relationship between 2026 me and 2016 or 2006 or 1996 or 1986 me.

The “From Nowhere to Nothing” podcast had an episode on “The Soul” recently. Joel Bouchard mentioned a thought experiment based on John Locke’s “The Prince and the Cobbler”. He said something like this: Imagine you’re a poor cobbler. You’re told that your soul could switch to the body of a prince, but you wouldn’t bring any of your own memories, emotions, etc.; you’d inherit his completely. Would you do it? Personally, I see no reason to say “yes”. If my “soul” is separate from memories, emotions, etc., then there’s nothing I can imagine that actually changes. If the soul is memories, emotions, etc., then the change matters; if it’s just some life force underlying those things, then it doesn’t matter. This is one reason why I find reincarnation mostly uncompelling. For many who believe in reincarnation, you don’t remember your past identities. You’re shaped by them (karma), but you don’t identify with them. This seems useful for justifying why one person has a good life and another has a difficult one; it seems useful for supporting the status quo. It doesn’t seem practical otherwise. Buddhism has a similar problem when it’s taught that rebirth from a previous physical form is not remembered; its strength lies when in a single life it presents the past us as making way for the present us, who is making way for the future us, because we can see the causality and we can identify with the past and future “I,” much like we identify with family and friends that we love. Insofar as “resurrection” maintains this sense of identity continuation, it seems more relevant (though this isn’t the same as saying it is “true”).

Is San Francisco the most complicated city in America?

The travel “vlogger” Alex Hunter posted a video about San Francisco on YouTube a week ago. He titled it “The Most Complicated City in America”:

As a travel video, it does a good job of capturing what makes “the City” so “complicated”. I have a list of books about San Francisco that I want to read. Unfortunately, I don’t know of a book that tries to address this phenomenon, the phenomenon of a city that people love or hate, that means something to liberals and conservatives alike, and that often means something quite the opposite to those parties.

Those who know me know that although I haven’t lived there since 2009, I remain obsessed with San Francisco, and that fourteen years in Texas and three in Oregon don’t change my perception of the Bay Area as “home”. Whenever something like a documentary about the city becomes available, I watch it:

I’ve been intrigued by how the media has lauded the new(ish) Mayor Daniel Laurie as someone who has turned the city around from its darker post-pandemic era.

And how people are speaking of a “renaissance”:

I’ll admit that when I visited last, which was in 2023, I was taken aback by what I saw. The fentanyl epidemic was devastating, as was the level of homelessness. While I don’t know what to think about Mayor Laurie in general, I agree that crime, lack of housing, homelessness, drug addiction, and overdoses aren’t progressive values, and that progressives do their cause a disservice when they fail to recognize this. I don’t know whether wealth inequality and the invasion of Silicon Valley values, especially the commitment to investing in Artificial Intelligence and the long history of supporting social media companies, should be viewed positively. I’m skeptical of the claim that the City is having a renaissance, since I worry that it’s a renaissance for the select few. But I’m hopeful because I want that city to thrive.

As much as I want it to thrive, I want someone to write a book on the “meaning” of San Francisco. If it exists, I wish someone would let me know. If it doesn’t, I wish someone would write it!